The Haramain High-Speed Railway transformed travel between the two holy cities, and many pilgrims now ask whether to take the train or a private taxi. Both are good options. The right choice depends on your group size, luggage, budget and where your hotels are. This guide compares them honestly so you can decide.
Quick Comparison
| Haramain Train | Private Taxi | |
|---|---|---|
| Door-to-door | No: taxi needed to and from both stations | Yes: hotel to hotel |
| Makkah station distance from Haram | About 6 km (Al Rusaifah) | Drop-off at your hotel |
| Madinah station distance from Masjid an-Nabawi | About 10 km | Drop-off at your hotel |
| Journey time Makkah–Madinah | Around 2.5–3 hours on the train, plus transfers and waiting | About 4.5–5 hours including a rest stop |
| Pricing | Per person | Per vehicle |
| Luggage | Limited: one large bag per passenger reported | All your bags, sized to your vehicle |
| Miqat stop for ihram | No stop: enter ihram before boarding | Driver stops at Dhul Hulayfah |
| Schedule | Fixed departures, can sell out in peak season | Leave whenever you are ready, 24/7 |
When the Haramain Train Is a Good Choice
- Solo travellers or couples with light luggage.
- Pilgrims who want the fastest time on the move and do not mind station transfers.
- Travellers comfortable with fixed timetables and booking ahead.
Economy fares between Makkah and Madinah have been reported from around 160 SAR per person one way, with business class higher. Prices change with demand, so always check the official Haramain booking channel.
When a Private Taxi Is Better
- Families and groups. A vehicle fare is shared. For example, our Hyundai H1 for 7 passengers costs 380 SAR from Makkah to Madinah, roughly 54 SAR per person.
- Elderly pilgrims and children. No stations, escalators or crowds with luggage.
- Lots of luggage. Umrah trips often involve big suitcases and Zamzam water.
- Ihram from Madinah. Your driver stops at Dhul Hulayfah (Abyar Ali) so you can change and make your intention calmly.
- Flexible timing. Leave after Fajr, after Jumu’ah or late at night.
- Ziyarat on the way. Some pilgrims choose the route via Badr to visit the site of the battle.
Real Cost Comparison for a Family of 5
By train, five economy tickets at around 160 SAR each come to about 800 SAR. Add a taxi from your Makkah hotel to the station and another from Madinah station to your hotel. By private taxi, a Hyundai Staria costs 400 SAR for the whole vehicle, hotel to hotel. For most families, the taxi is both cheaper and simpler. See all routes in our Umrah taxi fares guide.
The Best of Both: Taxi to and from the Station
If you prefer the train, we can still help. We offer fixed-price transfers from your hotel to the Makkah, Madinah or Jeddah train stations and from the station to your hotel, so you never have to queue for a taxi with your bags. See the “Hotel to Train Station” fares on our packages page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Haramain train faster than a taxi?
On the move, yes. Door to door, the gap narrows once you add station transfers, security and waiting time.
Does the train stop at the miqat?
No. If you travel from Madinah to Makkah for Umrah, you should be in ihram before boarding. A taxi can stop at Dhul Hulayfah for you.
Which is cheaper for a family?
For groups of 4 or more, a private taxi is usually cheaper because the fare is per vehicle.
Read More
Planning your intercity trip? Read our Makkah to Madinah taxi guide and how to choose Umrah transport.
Book Your Makkah–Madinah Taxi
WhatsApp or call +966 53 859 8496. Get your fixed intercity fare now.


